Durable Solutions, Safety Concerns, Stairs & Decks
GripStrips vs. HandiTreads Outdoor Non‑Slip Stair Treads: Which Is Right for You?
If you’re looking for a reliable way to make your outdoor steps safer, you’ve probably come across two common options: GripStrips (Made in Canada) and HandiTreads (Made in the USA). Both products aim to provide traction and reduce the risk of slipping on stairs, but they take very different approaches to solving the same problem.
In this post, we’ll break down the differences between GripStrips and HandiTreads, explore each feature in depth, and help you decide which solution is best for your home or business.
What Are GripStrips and What are HandiTreads?
GripStrips are rigid plastic strips with pointy spikes designed to be screwed directly into wood or concrete stair surfaces. They use molded spikes to provide traction and are generally marketed as an affordable DIY safety solution.
HandiTreads are aluminum stair treads with a patented raised-button surface that offers traction in all weather conditions. They’re designed to last for years with minimal maintenance and are commonly used in both residential and commercial settings.
Comparing GripStrips and HandiTreads
Here’s a quick look at how the two products stack up:
Feature | GripStrips | HandiTreads |
Material | Plastic (approx. ⅛” thick) | Heavy-duty aluminum |
Traction Surface | Molded spikes | Raised button traction pattern |
Attachment | Two screws per strip | Four+ color-matched stainless screws per tread |
Weather Resistance | May crack, warp, or loosen over time | Rust-proof, resists snow, salt, and debris |
Durability | Estimated 3–4 seasons | Lifetime residential warranty |
Installation | Quick DIY install | Pre-drilled, easy to install on any surface |
Comfort | Dangerous for barefoot use or for pet paws | Smooth enough for bare feet and pet paws |
Maintenance | May require re-tightening or replacing based on the expansion and contraction of the plastic | No upkeep required |
Warranty | None | Lifetime |
Material Matters
The most significant difference between GripStrips and HandiTreads comes down to what they’re made of.
GripStrips are constructed from a hard plastic material. While this makes them lightweight and inexpensive, it also makes them prone to cracking or becoming brittle in extreme cold. (video of me cracking a tread) Over time, exposure to sunlight can cause UV degradation, leading to warping or fading. Once the surface wears down, the molded cleats lose their effectiveness, and replacement becomes necessary.
HandiTreads, on the other hand, are crafted from heavy-duty aluminum. Aluminum is inherently rust-proof, able to withstand years of exposure to rain, snow, and salt without corroding. Unlike plastic, it won’t warp in the summer heat or crack in freezing winter temperatures. This means you can expect consistent performance year-round, no matter your climate.
Weather Resistance and Longevity
In outdoor applications, weather resistance is key. GripStrips, being plastic, can expand and contract with temperature changes. Over time, this can loosen the screws holding them in place or cause them to lift from the stair surface. In climates with freeze-thaw cycles, moisture can get trapped underneath and cause further damage to the strips or the stairs themselves.
HandiTreads are designed specifically for harsh outdoor environments. The aluminum body is impervious to rust and won’t degrade in the sun. Even when exposed to heavy snow or road salt, the surface remains intact. This durability means that HandiTreads are a one-time purchase backed by a lifetime residential warranty.
Installation Differences
GripStrips are thin and are supplied with four screws for attachment. While installation is quick, the limited fastening points can lead to movement over time, especially on stairs that see frequent use or in high-moisture environments.
HandiTreads come pre-drilled with 12 screw holes for a 30” tread and include color-matched stainless steel screws. This ensures a secure installation that resists loosening, even under heavy foot traffic or shifting temperatures. Plus, HandiTreads can be mounted on wood, composite, concrete, or brick steps—offering more versatility than GripStrips.
Comfort and Everyday Use
If you have children or pets who frequently use your stairs, comfort is an important factor. GripStrips, with their sharp cleats, can be uncomfortable or even hazardous to bare feet and animal paws. The rigid edges may also catch on footwear, increasing trip potential.
HandiTreads’ raised-button design is much smoother to the touch while still offering exceptional grip. This makes them an ideal choice for residential settings where safety needs to be balanced with comfort.
Maintenance and Replacement
GripStrips may require seasonal re-tightening or even replacement due to warping, cracking, or screw damage. In some cases, replacing one or two strips per season becomes an ongoing maintenance task.
HandiTreads require no upkeep. A quick sweep or rinse is usually enough to keep them clear of debris. Because the aluminum won’t corrode, there’s no need for repainting or refinishing.
Which Should You Choose?
If you’re on a very tight budget and only need a short-term traction solution for an area with mild weather, GripStrips may work for you. However, for most homeowners and businesses—especially those in climates with rain, snow, or ice—HandiTreads offer better value over time.
Choose GripStrips if:
- You need a quick, inexpensive, temporary fix
- Your stairs are sheltered from most weather
- You don’t mind frequent replacements
Choose HandiTreads if:
- You want a permanent, reliable, and attractive solution
- Your stairs are exposed to harsh weather conditions
- You need a barefoot- and pet-friendly option
- You want a product that works on multiple stair materials
Final Thoughts
Stair safety is about more than just preventing slips—it’s about choosing a solution that works year after year, in every season. GripStrips may be fine for limited applications, but HandiTreads provide the durability, comfort, and performance that make them a smarter long-term investment.
Explore the full line of HandiTreads aluminum stair treads and HandiTreads nosings today to find the perfect fit for your home or business stairs.